Honorable Mentions:
Let’s get things started with my Honorable Mentions for 2011. These are not necessarily the next highest ranked albums after my Top 25, but rather just some albums that I wanted to give extra attention to for one reason or another.
———-
Feist – Metals
In 2007, Feist broke out in grand fashion with her fantastic album The Reminder (with a little assist from Apple), and while Metals isn’t quite as immediate as its predecessor, it may actually be a more cohesive and complete album. You won’t find a “1234” on this release, but what you will find is a gorgeous set of songs, beautifully produced, that on repeated listens could very well be more fulfilling than anything in the Leslie Feist catalog.
[“The Bad In Each Other” – Metals]
———-
My Morning Jacket – Circuital
This is the kind of album My Morning Jacket needed to make after the disaster that was Evil Urges. (Now, let’s never speak of it again.) Jim James and crew got whatever the hell that was out of their system and returned to what they do best. It still doesn’t reach the heights of their best work, most notably 2005’s Z, but I really don’t expect them to ever get to that level again. Instead, we have an album full expansive southern rock tunes with just a hint of their psychedelic tendencies…just like we want them.
[“Victory Dance” – Circuital]
———-
James Blake – James Blake
Quite possibly the year’s hipster darling, James Blake released his debut album in 2011 to a great deal of buzz thanks to his very well received EP’s of 2010. A full album of Blake’s dubstep tunes is quite a lot to take in, but if you’re willing to take an hour with some headphones in, it’s easy to see the ability of this 23 year old Brit. The best description I’ve heard of Blake’s style, and one I like to pass on, is that of a Dubstep version of Bon Iver. He creates some incredibly sparse tunes, that somehow have so much depth beneath the surface. His version of bedroom pop is a divisive one among music lovers, but it’s hard to deny his inventiveness as you listen to his tunes, including a pretty excellent Feist cover.
[“Limit To Your Love” – James Blake]
———-
Wilco – The Whole Love
Much like the My Morning Jacket release, what I’m really praising here is a return to form. It’s not that I’ve hated Wilco’s last few albums, they’ve just been quite boring and pretty great examples of a band mailing it in. However, The Whole Love is Wilco’s finest release since 2005’s A Ghost Is Born, which is not something I was expecting…at all. They seem to be rejuvenated a bit here, offering more of the experimentation that made their early albums so intriguing. A more adventurous Wilco is a more interesting Wilco, and we are all the better for it.
[“Art of Almost” – The Whole Love]
———-
The Felice Brothers – Celebration, Florida
I have to give a shout out to some of my personal favorites, The Felice Brothers, by mentioning just how impressed I was with the direction the group went with their latest album Celebration, Florida. These guys were poised to benefit from the recent success of The Avett Brothers and Mumford & Sons, which I was quite ready for since I believe The Felice Brothers have been creating much more interesting folk music than their peers (especially Mumford), so it was quite a shock to see them depart from their folk roots and experiment with a more electronic dancehall sound. It doesn’t always work, as their ambitions do get the best of them at times, but I’ll be damned if I don’t respect the hell out the effort.
[“Ponzi” – Celebration, Florida]
Dishonorable Mentions
In the last few years, I haven’t really had a need for this category, and this year is no different really, but it’s a tradition so I’ll put something here anyway. Calling these Dishonorable Mentions is pretty harsh as they’re really not that bad. However, I don’t envision it to be quite as controversial as last year.
The Strokes – Angles
This certainly isn’t a bad album. It’s just one that was completely unnecessary. The Strokes released an amazing album in 2001 that ushered in an era of garage band Rock ‘n Roll, then followed it up with basically a carbon copy, and fizzled out with an uninspired third album. For some reason, they thought we really needed them to reunite. I suppose Angles is a bit better than it’s predecessor, but who really cares? It’s evident they don’t. Just call it a day, guys.
[“Under The Cover of Darkness” – Angles]
———-
Tapes ‘n Tapes – Outside
I present these guys as a great example of the hype machine getting a little bit out of control (see also, Clap Your Hands Say Yeah). When Tapes ‘n Tapes released their debut album in 2005 it was for some reason a critical success. I liked it alright, but found it a bit overrated. Their follow up album in 2008 pretty much vindicated my concerns by getting slammed critically and being labeled as a sophomore slump. (Personally, I thought it was on the same level of their debut…but whatever.) Well, with Outside, they’ve done nothing to really disprove that they were a mediocre band all along that for some reason found undeserving success on the internet blogosphere.
[“Freak Out” – Outside]
A Round of Sound 